Sheffield made 10 of 11 free throws. He added nine rebounds.
Julien Wooden had 10 points for the Dukes (8-12, 1-8).
Darius Banks, the Dukes' second leading scorer heading into the matchup at 14 points per game, shot only 19 percent in the game (3 of 16).
Elon matches up against Hofstra at home on Thursday. James Madison faces College of Charleston at home on Thursday.
For more AP college basketball coverage: https://apnews.com/Collegebasketball and http://twitter.com/AP-Top25
This was generated by Automated Insights, http://www.automatedinsights.com/ap, using data from STATS LLC, https://www.stats.com
No. 3 Villanova stunned by Virginia Tech in overtime
Keve Aluma scored 22 points and Nahiem Alleyne added 20 as Virginia Tech upset No. 3 Villanova 81-73 in overtime on Saturday night.
Cade Cunningham drops 20 as Oklahoma State routs Texas Southern
Cade Cunningham finishes with 20 points, four assists and two steals as Oklahoma State dominates Texas Southern 85-65.
USC defeats Montana 76-62; Evan Mobley scores 11 points
— Drew Peterson scored 13 points and Southern California defeated Montana 76-62 on Saturday night, with the Trojans getting points from all 10 of their players.