Jackson-Davis and Phinisee (11 points) were among five Hoosiers (6-4, 1-2 Big Ten) to score in double figures as Indiana was 57% shooting for the game (32 of 56). Aljami Durham added 18 points, Armaan Franklin had 16 and Trey Galloway 10.
Penn State (3-4, 0-3) scored first in overtime on a layup off the jump ball and Myreon Jones twice gave the Nittany Lions either a one-point lead or a tie — the latter, 85-85, coming off a pair of free throws with 43 seconds left.
But as the clock was winding down, Phinisee hit his winner with 13 seconds remaining and Penn State, after a timeout, missed a shot at the buzzer.
Sessoms had a potential game-winning 3-pointer blocked by Phinisee in the final second of regulation. Phinisee also blocked a Sessoms jump shot with 42 seconds left in regulation and Indiana clinging to a one-point lead.
Penn State hosts No. 6 Wisconsin on Sunday, Jan. 3 while Indiana hosts Maryland on Monday, Jan. 4.
Why college basketball's 'free year' is going to make for some difficult conversations
This year's seniors can return to college basketball next season, but is that what players and coaches really want?
No. 5 Illinois looks for home win vs Nebraska
Nebraska (5-16, 1-13) vs. No. 5 Illinois (16-6, 12-4)
Wyoming looks to extend streak vs San Jose St.
San Jose State (5-15, 3-13) vs. Wyoming (12-9, 6-8)